Property and Life Choices


How does owning (or not owning) real estate, and mortgage debt, influence the behaviour of individuals in their wider lives? What are the consequences of these patterns for whole nations?

Thor May
Brisbane, 2014



Preface: This is a discussion paper, not a researched academic document. The reading list at the end is mostly a collection of contemporary links from the Internet and pretty accidental, not edited for quality. Where a topic is of broad general interest comes up with friends, I have adopted the practice of posting discussion starters like the present one on in the hope that others might also find them worth thinking about. In spite of the caveats, this particular topic has been important to my working life, so the observations to follow are not merely casual.




1. Property is theft  (ahem..)


In 1840 the French anarchist, Pierre-Joseph Proudhon coined the phrase  property is theft! (La propriété, c'est le vol !).Property3.jpg Although he later criticized it himself, and Karl Marx considered it self-contradictory, this slogan became a propaganda underpinning for the total expropriation of private property by the wardens of so-called Communist states acting on behalf of  the masses . The outcome of course was a defacto reallocation of land holding from very large numbers of individuals to a small clique of those who had seized political power. Much later in countries such as Russia (when the USSR collapsed) and China (with generational devolution to a  red elite ) those power cliques also gained de jure control of the stolen assets. The consequences are still working through those societies.


2. Rural to urban migrations, and beyond


Communist-fueled radical changes in land holding during the 19th and 20th Centuries were not unique, either physically or in their political effects. For example the many English Enclosure Acts, which reached a culmination in the early 19th Century but had been proceeding for several centuries, drove vast numbers of peasants off their traditional landholdings without compensation, forcing them into cities as a new poor, and fuelled the labour pool for an industrial revolution (McElroy 2012). The new owners of seized lands were a ruling elite who created a complex legal code to buttress their own security.

These large internal population movements also led to forced and voluntary migration to  new lands in the Americas and Australasia. Rural to urban migration has become a feature of emerging market economies everywhere. Land tenure and housing have played and continue to play a central role in the process worldwide. At the moment China is in the midst of the largest rural to urban migration in human history.


3. The power of an urban working class


Ultimately, new urban classes acquire a kind of coercive power themselves by force of numbers, so the controllers of land and capital fnd it necessary to enter into a loose social contract for the exchange of labour as an input to industry. From the mid 19th Century this social contract drove a political revolution in the form of expanding representative democracy. To this day, the understanding of the democratic contract divides between those (typically the privileged) who essentially see it as a tool for social control by consent, and the bulk of the population who see democracy as an egalitarian tool for the fair distribution of power and resources.


4. Property ownership as a pacifying tool


It is well understood by most governments today, whatever their nominal ideology, that encouraging the private ownership of residential property is one of the most effective ways of ensuring social stability. A simple Australian example would be that after World War II, very large numbers of footloose demobilized soldiers could have been a distinct threat to the established order. It made very good political sense to direct them as soon as possible into stable employment, and into household ownership. My father, for example, who had minimal formal education, as an ex-soldier was offered both free trade training and loans for home house purchase on a very low government supported mortgage rate of about 2%. Of course, the governments of the day (mostly conservative) presented these opportunities as a big thank you to the brave men who had saved the nation.

Amongst the first acts of states which give up the lunacy of total centrally planned economic control is to move rapidly to create a residential owning middle class. As Russia formally abandoned communism in the early 1990s it did just that, allowing citizens to purchase their accommodation at very low cost. After Mao Zedong s death in 1976, China moved in exactly the same direction, even while maintaining a façade of communist ideology. The communist state of Vietnam has acted in exactly the same way. When you have a home and a mortgage, you are probably reluctant to start a revolution, and the political elites have a significant hold on your behaviour.


5. Property ownership as a metric of life success


Almost since its British foundation as a prison camp in 1788,  success in the colonies and then the nation of Australia has been predicated upon the possession of land, whether it was gifted, inherited, seized, or purchased. The continent of Australia is a very large chunk of dirt, much of it unsuitable for human habitation, but still with more thousands of square kilometers of emptiness than any Englishman might dream of. Nevertheless, the vast bulk of Australia s 23 million people continue to crowd into a handful of cities around the coast. Much of their life interest is obsessed with bidding up the price of real estate in these special urban locations. In critical ways the politics and economic activity of Australia continues to revolve around land. The systems of taxation in Australia are riddled with provisions relating to land holding and the possession of buildings. The finances of the many levels of government would become unsustainable, at least in their present intentions, without recourse to property taxation and the many activities which depend upon building construction. It has been estimated that 44% of the cost of new housing is sunk in taxation imposts of various kinds (Hurley 2012).


6. Cultural influences on home ownership


The value placed on home ownership is largely determined by culture. For example, in China today a prime qualification required to be an eligible bachelor is owning an apartment. Since men significantly outnumber women in many parts of China, while the capital requirements for housing purchase are beyond the reach of tens of millions, this is a serious source of social discontent. Making this discontent more bitter is that China now has tens of millions of unsold luxury apartments, indeed whole "empty cities" built by speculators in corrupt collusion with local government officials and wasted investment funds (and, incidentally, built with Australian steel).

Anglo-Saxon majority cultures, such as the Australian one, have nothing approaching China s culturally mandated matrimonial pressure on home ownership. The problem in Australia is simply that home ownership itself appears to be one of the main metrics for judging life success. My own birth family for example tends to consider me a  failure since I have shown little attachment to the property mantra. Some very prosperous nations have a very different perspective on home ownership. For example, Germany:

Europe's biggest economy has not had a single housing boom in the post-war period ...

That record comes courtesy of a cultural disinterest in home ownership, progressive social housing programs, conservative banking policies and government legislation that protects and encourages long-term renters.

Over the last decade, the ratio of house prices versus household incomes has been falling in Germany, and despite a slight pickup over recent years, it was still almost 17 per cent below its long-run average at the end of last year.

By contrast, Australia has the third-highest house price to income ratio in the world, at 4.3 times the average annual income according to the Australian Bureau of Statistics  [Bagshaw 2014].


7. Implicit disincentives for home ownership


The tenor of the discussion so far here has been that home ownership tends to stabilize the lives of most people because of the financial obligations and forced savings which mortgages impose, and because the act of possessing such a major asset in itself disinclines individuals to risky behaviour. Home ownership encourages people to remain in steady employment, and it can be a significant factor in personnel decisions about whether to hire when candidates seem equally matched. It is noted that owning property can be a major influence on matrimonial choice, especially for women, and especially where the raising of children is anticipated. We commented above that with the exception of the early  Communist aberration, governments worldwide have usually seen the value of having citizens who are settled with the highest possible level of home ownership. This provides a kind of security not just to the individuals directly involved, but reassures ruling elites that less privileged parts of the population will not take to the streets and forment revolution if they have something significant to lose.

In the light of the preceding paragraph it is interesting and a bit disturbing that in the last few decades there have been important forces moving to undermine the prospect of home ownership for young people. These forces are often unintended side effects of other decisions, and impact unevenly in particular cultures. A strong example would be the huge growth of tertiary student debt in the United States of America. It is gradually becoming apparent that this kind of student debt impacts negatively upon life choices for home ownership, employment, and even marriage (Korkki 2014, Konczal 2014, Brown 2013, Taieb 2013).


8. The effect of employment practices on home ownership


Another major influencing factor for instability would be changes in personnel practices and company management where most employees can no longer look forward to a lifetime engagement with one or even a few employers, and many are restricted to part-time jobs or outsourced work. With management taking a predatory short-term approach, and evading responsibility for in-house training and mentoring, it is not surprising that many younger workers adopt a frankly opportunistic outlook to company employment and become somewhat wary of taking on long term debt. In many countries, post-GFC prospects for employment or a career by younger workers have become an impossible dream. Buying a house is the last thing they can contemplate. Their best hope lies in mobility, sometimes international mobility.


9. Consumer debt as a disincentive for property debt


A third factor influencing long term commitment has been an ever spiraling acceleration of consumer consumption, heavily promoted by business itself, which has inevitably led to a large part of the population carrying unsustainable consumer debt and surrendering to a mentality of  live for the day .  The  greed is good creed  amongst captains of industry and their political servants is eventually bound to have a psychological blowback amongst the common people who must buy the products of industry for it to profit, yet find that they have become unsure of how to pay the bills next month, let alone on a 20 year mortgage commitment.


10. The contradictory effects of property ownership and debt on life choices


This topic could be summarized by the proposition that property ownership, and especially the debt that often goes with it, has multiple and sometimes contradictory effects on individual behaviour. In the Australian context, the ratio of income to housing purchase costs looks rationally unsustainable. That ratio is one of the highest in the world, and historically elsewhere this kind of imbalance has led to property price crashes. However the Australian situation has continued to defy gravity for quite a long time, perhaps buoyed by immigration and a mining boom (which is now tailing off).


11. The not-so-hidden influence of taxation on property ownership


I think that housing prices in Australia - and probably in other countries too - are only indirectly a product of the very popular use of property as everyman's investment vehicle. The whole deal is made possible in Australia by the taxation system (negative gearing on leveraged property especially, plus the absence of a capital gains tax) and the taxation system is driven in complicated ways by the political system. Both major parties have a taxation tiger by the tail and they don't know how to let go of it. Other paradigms are possible, such as the German example given earlier, but nobody knows how to get from here to there (and of course Germany has its own flavour of problems). Major change in Australia may come as an unintended consequence of other things (e.g. a collapse of the China trading relationship), but is unlikely to be pleasant and won t be voluntary. One possible solution to the taxation dilemma, and hence indirectly to the housing tax problem, would be to find a way to force corporations to make the kind of real tax contribution to the society which was normal in the 1950s. This is a transnational issue. The following example (Ritholtz 2011) from the United States illustrates a worldwide pattern:


Corporate Taxes as a Percentage of Federal Revenue
1955 . . . 27.3%
2010 . . . 8.9%

Corporate Taxes as a Percentage of GDP
1955 . . . 4.3%
2010 . . . 1.3%

Individual Income/Payrolls as a Percentage of Federal Revenue
1955 . . . 58.0%
2010 . . . 81.5%



Reading list (note that the writers in these links are expressing their own views. I don't necessarily share them.  


AFP (October 25, 2011) "Obama bypasses Congress with mortgage plan". Brisbane Times online @

APM (17 August 2014) "Property Research Report for Nundah 4012". Australian Property Monitor, Domain website @

Badkar, Mamta (June 10 2014) "China's Most Famous Ghost City Got Even Worse In The Last 4 Years". Business Insider website, online @

Bagshaw, Eryk (June 27, 2014) "Tell 'em they're dreaming - Australian housing obsession is holding us back". Sydney Morning Herald, online @

Boone, Mary (Feb 15 2013) "8 Tax Breaks Every Homeowner Should Know About". Businessinsider website, online @

Bosque Homs, Daniel (February 23, 2013) "Firefighters refuse to help evict families". [Spain] Brisbane Times online @

Boyd, Carolyn (July 3, 2012) "Homes don't buy happiness". Brisbane Times online @

Brown, Meta and Sydnee Caldwell (April 17, 2013) "Young Student Loan Borrowers Retreat from Housing and Auto Markets".  Liberty Street Economics website, online @

Brown, Robbie (July 30, 2012) "Older Americans lose homes as great recession takes toll". Brisbane Times online @

Centre for International Economics (September 2011)  Taxation of the Housing Sector . Centre for International Economics website, report online @

Chirico, Kristin (Oct. 16, 2013) "23 Surprisingly Gorgeous Homes Made From Shipping Containers". Buzzfeed website,online @

D'Arcy, Jayne (April 27, 2014) "Airbnb: Spare room revolution". Sydney Morning Herald, online @

Dodson, Jago and Neil Sipe (2008) "Unsettling Suburbia: The New Landscape of Oil and Mortgage Vulnerability in Australian Cities". [some revealing urban maps] Urban Research Program, Research Paper 17, Griffith University, online @

Dowall, David E. (January 1999) "Globalization, Structural Change and Urban Land Management". Land Lines: January 1999, Volume 11, Number 1. Lincoln Institute of Land Policy; website online @

Drake Homes (2014) "Types Of Homes Moved and Recycled in Australia". Drake Homes online @

Dumas, Daisy (August 9, 2014) "Enter the tiny house, the McMansion antidote on wheels". Sydney Morning Herald online @

Duncan Hughes, Duncan (July 18, 2014) "Warnings sound on DIY-super property". Sydney Morning Herald, online @

Feeney, Katherine (December 21, 2012) "Brisbane's population loss is Gold Coast's gain". Brisbane Times online @

Ferguson, Adele (August 16, 2014) "Macquarie's bombshell a call to arms". Sydney Morning Herald, online @

Ferguson, Adele and Ben Butler (August 16, 2014) "Cheating rife in financial planning". Sydney Morning Herald, online @

Gibson, Anne (July 13, 2013) "Owner walks away from $2.1m home". New Zealand Herald, online @

Gittins, Ross (August 18, 2014) "Stop wasting our money on infrastructure". Sydney Morning Herald online @

Global Property Guide (2014) "Country investment ratings". Global Property Guide website, online @

Global Property Guide (June 11, 2014) "Q1 2014: Global house price boom continues". Global Property Guide website, online @

Goldin, Melissa (24 April 2014) "Chinese Company Builds Houses Quickly With 3D Printing". Mashable website, online @

Goodboy, Dave (Oct 28, 2011) "Tax Benefits For Homeowners". Investopedia website, online @

Guilford, Gwynn (Sep 19 2013) "The Connection Between China's One-Child Policy and Its Housing Bubble - The fierce competition among bachelors to purchase homes has distorted a market in a way that could threaten the economy as a whole". The Atlantic, online @ 

Hall, Craig (9th Apr 2014) "Is property a good investment?". YourLifeChoices website, online @

Han Fei (February 19, 2013) "Chinese Real Estate Records Pulled from Public Scrutiny". Sound of Hope Radio online @

He Dan and Huang Yiming (2012-02-13) "Hainan province mulls tax on vacant homes". China Daily online @

Harris, Catherine (22/12/2012) "Are leasehold properties a good buy?" [New Zealand] Stuff website, online @

Hurley, Ben (11 Apr 2012) "House prices up to 44pc tax: HIA report". Australian Financial Review, online @  

Hutchens, Gareth (October 22, 2014) "Why negative gearing should be abolished".  

InspirationGreen (n.d.) "Earth Sheltered Homes". InspirationGreen website, online @

Janda, Michael (15 Jan 2014) "Home buyer beware: the illusion of affordability". Australian Broadcasting Commission, online @

Janda, Michael (30 Jun 2014) "Special taxes considered by parliamentary inquiry into foreign real estate investors". Australian Broadcasting Organization, online @

Kim Jung-yoon (21 January 201) "Single households influence grows". Joong Ang Daily (South Korea), online @|home|newslist1

Johnstone, Toby (January 28, 2014) "Plans for vertical farms on unit blocks take off". Brisbane Times online @

Korkki, Phillis(24 May 2014) "The Ripple Effects of Rising Student Debt". New York Times online @

Konczal, Mike (June 24, 2014} "The Devastating, Lifelong Consequences of Student Debt". The New Republic, online @

Lane, Robert (March 1998) "Transfer of Development Rights for Balanced Development". [Rural to urban development]. Land Lines: March 1998, Volume 10, Number 2. Lincoln Institute of Land Policy; website online @

Limonov, Leonid (April 2002) "Land Reform and Property Markets in Russia". Land Lines: April 2002, Volume 14, Number 2. Lincoln Institute of Land Policy; website online @

Madigan, Nicole (July 28, 2014) "Brisbane best for rental yields". Sydney Morning Herald, online @

Marriner, Cosima (June 8, 2014) "Struggling pensioners opt to leave Australia for a cheaper country". Sydney Morning Herald online @

McElroy, Wendy (March 8, 2012) "The Enclosure Acts and the Industrial Revolution". Explore Freedom website, online @

Moore, Tony (August 23, 2014) "Inside Brisbane's billion dollar inner-city land debate". Brisbane Times online @

Morgenson, Gretchen (April 28, 2014} "How Wall Street insiders stacked the deck in Washington". Sydney Morning Herald online @

NCBI(2011 Oct 13) "Housing strain, mortgage foreclosure, and health". US National Library of Medicine National Institutes of Health. Nurs Outlook. 2012 May-Jun;60(3):134-42, 142.e1. doi: 10.1016/j.outlook.2011.08.004. Epub . Website online @

Newsom, McKellar (August 25, 2012) "Violations and Vouchers: An Interview with a Section 8 Police Officer". [Tennessee, USA] The Bigger Pockets blog, online @

Nicholson, Larissa (March 4, 2013) "Adelaide the country's most liveable city". Sydney Morning Herald, online @

Peacock, Craig (August 2014 and back) "Who crashed the economy?". Who Crashed the Economy? blog, online @    

Pollard, Ruth (December 4, 2012) "Israel faces rebuke over settlement plans". Brisbane Times online @

Potts, David (August 20, 2014) "Can you afford it? Can you afford to ignore it?". Brisbane Times online @

Nicholls, Stephen (July 18, 2014) "Chinese billionaire's big plans for Sydney - The Chinese developer behind the city's tallest residential tower says this is just the beginning". Brisbane Times, online @

Nicholls, Stephen (June 2, 2014) "Property prices head south". Brisbane Times, online @

Nicholls, Stephen (June 30, 2014) "Confusion reigns: RP Data says home values rise". Sydney Morning Herald, online @

Numbeo (2014) "Property Prices Index 2014". Numbeo comparison website, online @

Pascoe, Michael (July 28, 2014) "Mortgage fears unfounded as the yield chase gallops on". Sydney Morning Herald, online @

Pilger, John (2013) "Australia's nasty Utopia". Asia Times online @

Pollard, Ruth (November 26, 2011) "Egypt's poor await their true revolution - City of the Dead". Brisbane Times online @

Potts, David (August 20, 2014) "Can you afford it? Can you afford to ignore it?". Brisbane Times online @

Prince, Rosa (July 23, 2014) "Manhattan apartment block's door for poor". Sydney Morning Herald, online @

Real Estate Investar (February 2, 2010) "Australia s Top Rental Yield Suburbs and Property". Real Estate Investar website @

Remeikis, Amy (May 29, 2013) "Funding offer won't dictate policy on tenant service: LNP". Brisbane Times online @

Remeikis, Amy (April 12, 2013) "Tenants group faces eviction". Brisbane Times online @

Robinson, Elly and Rennell Adams (2008) "Housing stress and the mental health and wellbeing of families". Australia Family Relationships Clearing House website, online @

Reuters (2014-08-18) "War on corruption drives money away to Australia". China Daily online @

Roberts, Sam (February 1, 2012) "Racial segregation in US at an all-time low". Brisbane Times online @

Shapiro, Jonathon (July 24, 2014) "Negative gearing pumping house prices, but they're not overvalued yet". Sydney Morning Herald, online @

Silva, Kristian (June 11, 2014) "Neighbours plus tourists equals high crime on the glitter strip". Brisbane Times online @

Sisci, Francesco (Dec 21, '12) "Xi has to get the party started. [references China's transition to private housing in the 1990s, and the political consequences] Asia Times online @ Skwirk Interactive Schooling (2014) "Australia's Social and cultural history in the post war period - the housing boom".

Skwirk Interactive Schooling website online @

SmallHouseBliss (August 2014) "Small House Designs with Big Impact". SmallHouseBliss website, online @

South Pacific Review (9 December 2011) "How to Buy Real Estate in Chile". South Pacific Review online @

Spooner, Rania (April 18, 2012) "Fly-in fly-out saves millions, Fortescue tells inquiry". Brisbane Times, online @

The Guardian (19 March 2014) "Historic Sydney waterfront public housing to be sold and tenants evicted". The Guardian online @

Thomson, Jimmy (January 14, 2014) "Landlords in hot water over urgent repairs". Brisbane Times online @

Thomson, Jimmy (July 15, 2014) "Form guide for informal lets". Brisbane Times online @

Taieb, Steven N. (June 1, 2003) "The Debt Trap: How Your Life Choices Impact on Your Financial Future". pub. Rainbow Books, online @

Waterfield, Bruno (December 4, 2012) "Amsterdam to expel nuisance neighbours". Brisbane Times online @

West, Michael (August 16, 2014) "Sophisticated or not, we're open for funny business". Sydney Morning Herald, online @

Whittaker, Noel (June 17, 2014) "Costly exit from retirement investment". Brisbane Times online @

Wikipedia (2014) "Negative gearing (Australia)". Wikipedia online @

Wikipedia(2014) "Home ownership in Australia". Wikipedia online @

Wikipedia (2014) "Transition Economy". [A transition economy or transitional economy is an economy which is changing from a Soviet-type centrally planned economy to a market economy]. Wikipedia online @

Wikipedia (2014) "Shipping container architecture". Wikipedia online @

Wikipedia (2014) "Small house movement". Wikipedia online @

Wikipedia (2014)  Das Kapital, Kritik der politischen Ökonomie by Karl Marx . Wikipedia online @

Wikipedia (2014) "Property is Theft!". Wikipedia online @!

Your Mortgage (n.d) "Mortgage Tax". Your Mortgage website, online @

Zaw, Yolanda (March 28, 2013) "Taxes 40pc of new home cost". The West Australian, online @

Zhou, Christina (December 17, 2013) "Half of home owners plan renovations, study shows". Brisbane Times online @

Zhou, Christina (June 19, 2014) "Living in a box: homes made from shipping containers". Brisbane Times, online @




Source of this essay

meetup group: Brisbane Active Thinking Meetup

topics already discussed:

comments: Thor May -



Professional bio: Thor May has a core professional interest in cognitive linguistics, at which he has rarely succeeded in making a living. He has also, perhaps fatally in a career sense, cultivated an interest in how things work  people, brains, systems, countries, machines, whatever& In the world of daily employment he has mostly taught English as a foreign language, a stimulating activity though rarely regarded as a profession by the world at large. His PhD dissertation, Language Tangle, dealt with language teaching productivity. Thor has been teaching English to non-native speakers, training teachers and lecturing linguistics, since 1976. This work has taken him to seven countries in Oceania and East Asia, mostly with tertiary students, but with a couple of detours to teach secondary students and young children. He has trained teachers in Australia, Fiji and South Korea. In an earlier life, prior to becoming a teacher, he had a decade of finding his way out of working class origins, through unskilled jobs in Australia, New Zealand and finally England (after backpacking across Asia in 1972).


academic repository: at  

discussion: Thor's Unwise Ideas at

personal site:

Property and life choices (c) Thor May 2014


 return to homepage